Eisner & Thompson

In reading Will Eisner’s A Contract With God and Craig Thompson’s Blankets, there are several similarities between their approaches to graphic storytelling that make themselves apparent; the most obvious one being, their autobiographical nature, and dealing with the themes of spirituality and God.

A Contract With God presents a cultural memory and the harsh reality of the tenements in New York during the 1930s. Blankets is an intricate and earnest account of its creator’s coming of age. Both are not only beautiful works of art but also complex pieces of literature that don’t shy away from serious subject matter.

Both Eisner and Thompson take a non-linear approach to the narrative but maintain clear sense continuity through emotions and actions, its almost cinematic. Thompson makes interesting use of transitional devices often used in film editing. That combined with his expressive use of brushstrokes to create flow and movement really makes the pacing in Blankets stand out.

Both their works consist of a fleeting sense of nostalgia and a dreamlike recollection of events and experiences, weaving a story stringing together memories from different times of life. As Denny O’Neil puts it while introducing A Contract With God, they seem like adult’s attempts to make whole their childhood experiences, combining the past and the present into a single experience.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Left-Field Funnies

I had no idea what to expect going into this having no prior knowledge of the underground comics movement. When I received this particular comic to read, I must say I was a little disappointed looking at the cover. I guess I expected the cover to look more mature- like it really did have offensive content inside. But of course, as they say, don't judge a book by its cover so I dived into it. I was pleasantly surprised to find that Left-Field Funnies didn't seem to be offensive just for the sake of it. It seemed to present some genuine insights and criticisms about the 'hippie' movement and the intellectualization of the escapist ideologies in a satirical and crass manner. Not that I agree with everything being said, I do think it is an interesting perspective because I usually only come across a romanticized version of the movement in recent media. Especially because, from what I've gathered from today's class, underground comics culminated out of the movement ...
Read more

Maus by Art Spiegelman

Art Spiegelman’s Maus is a deeply impactful and memorable work but by no means an easy read; stories of cruelty that we, as a society are capable of, never can be. The very first words I noted down for my response were “it hurts.” Though the tone of the narrative feels devoid of sentimentality, you can’t help but grieve with him, for him. For the suffering of his family and his own burden of guilt for not having had to suffer similarly; for the loss of the opportunity to reconcile with his father; for the loss of his mother, her story, and several other stories that will remain untold. With Maus , Spiegelman makes us confront the harsh reality of the Holocaust and the horrifying mark it has left on generations to come, while he himself attempts to confront the root and nature of his own sorrow. The crudeness of his drawings emphasizes the harshness of that/this world. He parallels his father’s story of the Holocaust with his own interactions with his father and m...
Read more